Offense MVP: Troy's Fighting Irish - Andre McCauley (RB)
Co-Defense MVP: Buffalo Gladiators - Aaron Dominisey (SS)
Co-Defense MVP: Lyndonville Tigers - Joe Suhr (LB)
Special Teams MVP: Lyndonville Tigers - Ricky McVay
Rookie of the Year: Jamestown Chiefs - Anthony Hammer
Coach of the Year: Troy's Fighting Irish - Manny Everett

QB  Troy's Fighting Irish - Ryan Job
HB  Troy's Fighting Irish - Andre McCauley
FB  Troy's Fighting Irish - Bryan Sheldon
TE  Buffalo Gladiators - Matt Silver
WR  Buffalo Gladiators - Matt O'Malley
WR  Lyndonville Tigers - Royce Haynes
LT  Buffalo Gladiators - Chris Marshall
LG  Troy's Fighting Irish - Tony Buchanan
C   Troy's Fighting Irish - Allen Preston
RG  Buffalo Gladiators - Dave Kryczyk
RT  Buffalo Gladiators - Scott Orway
DE  Buffalo Gladiators - Richard Zee
DE  Troy's Fighting Irish - Anthony Murray
DT  Lyndonville Tigers - Jon Ostrander
DT  Troy's Fighting Irish - Jeremy Rogers
MLB Troy's Fighting Irish - Joshiah Quinn
MLB Southern Tier Diesel - JR Bennion
OLB Buffalo Gladiators - Joe Moore
OLB Lyndonville Tigers - Joe Suhr
CB  Buffalo Gladiators - Nick Cyna
CB  Southern Tier Diesel - Stanley Gilchrist
SS  Buffalo Gladiators - Aaron Dominisey
FS  Troy's Fighting Irish - DJ McKeon
K   Lyndonville Tigers - Mat Whiting
P   Southern Tier Diesel - Chad Hancock
KR/PR Lyndonville Tigers - Ricky McVay

QB  Jamestown Chiefs - Lamont Rhim
HB  Troy's Fighting Irish - Neil Keels
FB  Southern Tier Diesel - Donnie Moore
TE  Jamestown Chiefs - Anthony Azevedo
WR  Troy's Fighting Irish - Sean Bergin
WR  Oneida County Titans - Rob Yager
LT  Lyndonville Tigers - Tim Conley
LG  Lyndonville Tigers - Curtis Childs
C   Buffalo Gladiators - Greg Davis
RG  Troy's Fighting Irish - Larredick Lewis
RT  Troy's Fighting Irish - Sean Maille
DE  Troy's Fighting Irish - James Rigney
DE  Southern Tier Diesel - Chad Hancock
DT  Lyndonville Tigers - Joe Sands
DT  Buffalo Gladiators - Pete Gittere
MLB Lyndonville Tigers - Ian Weatherbee
MLB Watertown Revolution - Andrew Shaw
OLB Jamestown Chiefs - Anthony Hammer
OLB Troy's Fighting Irish - Tommy Mazzariello
CB  Troy's Fighting Irish - Fred Job
CB (tied) Buffalo Gladiators - Chris Williams
CB (tied) Oneida County Titans - Nick Smith
SS Jamestown Chiefs - Jake Wilcznski
FS Jamestown Chiefs - Keith Adams
K  Jamestown Chiefs - Anthony Hammer
P  Jamestown Chiefs - Anthony Hammer
KR/PR Southern Tier Diesel - Stanley Gilchrist

QB  Lyndonville Tigers - Ricky McVay
QB  Buffalo Gladiators - John Augustine
HB  Buffalo Gladiators - Robert Fleeca
HB  Oneida County Titans - Justin Pearson
FB  Lyndonville Tigers - Nate Wright
FB  Oneida County Titans - Dustin Seymour
TE  Lyndonville Tigers - Cliff Brown
TE  Southern Tier Diesel - Chad Hancock
WR  Buffalo Gladiators - Lee Flores
WR  Jamestown Chiefs - Joe Battaglia
WR  Southern Tier Diesel - Jason Folland
WR  Troy's Fighting Irish - Brandon Hill
LT  Troy's Fighting Irish - Mike Chura
LT  Jamestown Chiefs - Marc Scapelitte
LG  Buffalo Gladiators - Tim Zee
LG  Southern Tier Diesel - Nick Bocharski
C   Lyndonville Tigers - Scott Blount
C   Southern Tier Diesel - Kirk Rowland
RG  Oneida County Titans - Chad McClean
RG  Southern Tier Diesel - Dave Stryker
RT  Lyndonville Tigers - Justin Miller
RT  Southern Tier Diesel - Seth Hostuttler
DE  Lyndonville Tigers - Nate Wright
DE  Cortland Bulldogs - Shaquan McKnight
DE  Buffalo Gladiators - Brandon Hoerner
DE  Oneida County Titans - Jason Pearson
DT  Troy's Fighting Irish - Jeremy Tryon
DT  Buffalo Gladiators - Desmond Thompson
DT  Watertown Revolution - Jeff Shorkey
DT  Southern Tier Diesel - Bill Johnston
MLB Jamestown Chiefs - Anthony Robles
MLB Buffalo Gladiators - Nelson McCoullough
MLB Jamestown Chiefs - Frank Vicary Jr.
MLB Southern Tier Diesel - Donnie Moore
OLB Jamestown Chiefs - Mark Brooks
OLB Buffalo Gladiators - Jesse Schmiegel
OLB Southern Tier Diesel - Karl Rowland
OLB Lyndonville Tigers - Joel Fidanza
CB  Troy's Fighting Irish - Jared Blais
CB  Jamestown Chiefs - Billy Giambelluca
CB  Jamestown Chiefs - Danny Holand
SS  Troy's Fighting Irish - Josh Brown
SS  Watertown Revolution - Greg Riley
FS  Buffalo Gladiators - Jeff Hand
FS  Lyndonville Tigers - Mike Manicki
K   Buffalo Gladiators - Kyle Kreitchfield
K   Troy's Fighting Irish - Bobby Hummel
P   Troy's Fighting Irish - Bobby Hummel
P   Buffalo Gladiators - Owen Buehler
KR/PR Oneida County Titans - Justin Pearson
KR/PR Buffalo Gladiators - Jacob Lew